Reservation
(718) 894-7915
Visit Us
74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 11379
Hello dear
Welcome To Carlo's Pizza Middle Village
At Carlo's Pizza Middle Village, we celebrate a rich tradition of crafting delicious, authentic New York-style pizza. Nestled in the heart of Middle Village, our pizzeria has become a beloved staple since 1966, offering a warm, casual atmosphere complemented by friendly service. We pride ourselves on our diverse menu, featuring everything from classic pepperoni slices to innovative specialties like the Peter Lugar Steak Pie, all made with quality ingredients. Our commitment to community shines through our offerings, including vegetarian options and homemade pasta. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or catering for a group, Carlo's Pizza promises a delightful experience for all.
About
Carlo's Pizza Middle Village
Welcome to Carlo's Pizza Middle Village—a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Middle Village, New York. Since its opening, this establishment has cultivated a reputation for delivering mouthwatering pizza and comfort food, paired with the warmth of a friendly neighborhood pizzeria. Located at 74-02 Metropolitan Ave and reachable at (718) 894-7915, Carlo's Pizza invites you to indulge in a culinary experience where tradition meets taste.
The menu at Carlo's is a delightful tapestry of flavors, boasting options that cater to every palate. From their classic pepperoni pizza to unique specialty pies like the Peter Lugar Steak Pie—marinated steak topped with mozzarella cheese—there’s something for everyone. And let’s not forget the crowd-favorite Carlos Mike's Hot Honey Pepperoni Pie, where sweet meets spicy for an unforgettable bite.
- Steaks & Burgers: If you're in the mood for something heartier, the skirt steak dishes are a must-try. For $32, you can savor the rich flavors enhanced by cherry peppers and onions.
- Pasta Delight: Dive into their lobster ravioli at $18, featuring fresh lobster enveloped in delicate pasta, or taste their homemade pesto sauce on your choice of pasta for a burst of flavor.
- Homemade Goodies: Customers rave about Carlo's signature garlic knots and homemade sauces, a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor.
Feedback from patrons reflects the authentic charm of Carlo's. As noted by Michael K, it is a "good neighborhood pizzeria with ample seating," where the standout Sicilian pizza leaves a lasting impression. The reliability of their offerings has led families like that of Irene M. Cruz to make Carlo’s a staple during their visits home—a true symbol of New York pizza culture.
With every visit, you’ll find that the warm, fresh-baked bread and welcoming service create a convivial atmosphere. Lee Stat remarked on the freshness of the chicken parmesan served on their homemade bread, enhancing the overall dining experience.
For an authentic slice of Middle Village, Carlo's Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a cherished part of the community fabric. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or settling in for a meal with friends and family, you will leave with not only a satisfied appetite but also fond memories.
Don't miss out—make your way to Carlo's Pizza Middle Village and experience the blend of tradition, flavor, and community spirit that has made this pizzeria a local treasure since 1966!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Good neighborhood pizzeria with ample seating. I had their Sicilian. Good food, reasonable prices. They even sell their own pasta and sauce. ”
“ I eat here everytime we come into town to visit family and it is NY pizza to the max. The guys behind the counter are friendly and cool to talk to. They have alot of options and everything including their garlic knots is really tasty. You wont be disappointed. I find it a bit pricey as 2 slices of pepperoni pizza is 10 but it seems inflation has affected everyone. ”
“ The bread that came out was warm and fresh and absolutely delicious. The steak salad was well cooked and tasty. The chicken parmesan was fresh and on the homemade bread. The service was excellent and very friendly. The place was very clean including the bathroom. ”
“ Best Pizza in the Neighborhood. Rosas is closer to where I live but we actually walk past it to Carlos instead for over 15 years. 1st thing we do when we land home from any vacation is order Carlos Pizza. their beef patty with cheese is delicious. The guys behind the counter are great too, always friendly. ”
“ Carlos pizza is a must try when in Middle Village! Excellent regular slice, pepperoni bites and very good value for the price. I suggest leaving with a jar of their special homemade sauce, since 1966! ”
“ This place, these guys, this food... man... TOP OF THE LINE, HEART OF AUTHENTICITY,... this place Exemplifies the definition of what NY and pizza is all about. Family owned, the staff here along with the food explains why they have been in business over 5 decades. Just stop in, relax and witness what pizza, family and what NY is all about. Definitely will make it a point to stop back in when in this area. Steven and the familyCharlotte ”
“ I dont know which one is better grandma style pizza or the fellas that work at Carlos. You always hear New Yorkers are rude!!! I didnt find that to be the true within the 4 walls of Carlos. Between the 4 in my crew, we had margaritas, egg plant, grandma style, bbq chicken and white vodka. All were good, but bbq pizza seemed to be the crews favorite. Definitely check them out and make sure to leave a HUGE tip!! ”
“ Great clean place with a friendly staff. This place has a great variety of Italian food that tastes amazing for a very good price. I would highly recommend anyone to come here if they love Italian food. I also recommend theyre rigatoni with vodka sauce its just perfect ”